Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-80.187.103.142-20150309120420/@comment-15636815-20150309134518

Ah, okay. I think I have the answer.

When it asks you whether you want to sign in or create a new account, I believe it's talking about your Wikia account. I see you here as "A Wikia contributor", which means you either don't have a Wikia account or you're not logged in to it.

Before you can connect your Wikia account to your Facebook account, you need actually to have a Wikia account with which to connect. In addition, Wikia sort of needs to know which account is yours, so it makes the right connection. Sort of obvious, really, but there it is. ;-)